Indonesia's Economic Growth Slows in Q3

Advertisements

The recent economic reports from the Central Statistics Agency of Indonesia reveal a notable slowdown in the country's growth trajectory, sparking discussions among economists and policymakers alikeIn the third quarter of 2024, Indonesia's economy grew at a rate of only 4.95%, falling short of the 5% benchmarkThis figure reflects a downward trend when compared to the previous quarters, with the first quarter standing at 5.11% and the second at 5.05%. Essentially, this is the lowest quarterly growth rate observed since the third quarter of 2023, raising concerns about the broader trends shaping the Indonesian economy.

Amalia, the acting head of the Central Statistics Agency, elaborated on the numbers, attributing the underwhelming growth to seasonal economic patterns that are historically evident in IndonesiaA look back at previous years confirms this seasonal fluctuation: the third quarter of 2023 saw a growth rate of 4.94%, while the same period in 2022 recorded just 4.83%. This consistent pattern indicates that economic growth typically dips in the third quarter, a trend possibly linked to Indonesia's unique industrial structure and prevailing consumer habits.

Examining sectoral performance provides a clearer picture of the economic landscape

The data revealed that eight significant industries fell short of the overall economic growth rateManufacturing, which plays a crucial role in Indonesia's economy by contributing nearly 19.02% to the GDP, grew modestly at just 4.72% during the third quarterOther sectors that lagged behind included agriculture, trade, mining, and educational servicesOn the flip side, industries such as construction, transportation and warehousing, information and communication, financial services, and health services saw growth exceeding that of the overall economy, indicating a divergence in sectoral performance.

Geographically, the growth disparities extend to different regions across IndonesiaNotably, only Sumatra and Java experienced lower growth rates than the national average, with Sumatra at 4.48%, slightly below the previous year's figure of 4.49%. Java showed modest improvement, recording a growth rate of 4.92%, just a notch higher than its year-on-year performance of 4.84%. Contrastingly, provinces like Maluku and Papua led the pack with a higher growth rate of 6%, albeit lower than last year's impressive 9.10%. Sulawesi followed closely with a 5.87% growth, down from 6.42% the previous year, and Bali and Nusa Tenggara reported a rise to 5.28%, well above the 3.43% witnessed last year.

One of the pivotal factors contributing to the overall economic sluggishness in the third quarter is the lackluster household consumption

Household spending is a fundamental component of the national economy, accounting for approximately 53.08% of total economic activityHowever, in the third quarter of 2024, household consumption only managed to grow by 4.91%, below the rate of economic growth and thereby continuing the waning consumption trends observed since the previous yearFor context, household consumption growth reached 5.05% in the third quarter of 2023 and peaked at 5.40% in 2022.

The actual economic growth figures for the third quarter have missed analysts' initial projectionsIndonesian Finance Minister Sri Mulyani had previously indicated expectations for a sustained growth trend of over 5% continuing from the first and second quartersSimilarly, the Coordinating Minister for Economic Affairs, Airlangga Hartarto, suggested a target growth rate of 5.05% for this period.

Meanwhile, economists from institutions such as the University of Indonesia have expressed skepticism about achieving growth rates above 5% in the third quarter

Tuhuku Rifki attributed this hesitation to several factors, including a conspicuous lack of new economic growth drivers, subdued purchasing power, and minimal seasonal influences—elements critical to stimulating economic dynamism.

The implications of the economic slowdown become even more significant as Indonesia approaches its full-year growth targetsThe government has set an ambitious annual growth target of 5.2%; however, this may be challenging to achieve, given that the growth recorded from January to September was merely 5.03%. The persistent weaknesses in consumer purchasing power, coupled with ongoing contractions in the manufacturing sector, continue to cast a shadow over economic projectionsData from October indicated a manufacturing Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) of just 49.2, firmly placing Indonesia's manufacturing sector in a contraction phase for four consecutive months

alefox

The Indonesian Ministry of Industry has warned that without substantial policy shifts to bolster manufacturing, this contraction is likely to endure.

Despite these hurdles, there remains optimism for achieving over 5% growth for the entirety of 2024. Historical trends suggest that the fourth quarter generally benefits from higher growth rates compared to the third quarter, as evidenced by 2022 and 2023 where growth rates reached 5.01% and 5.04%, respectivelyRifki anticipates Indonesia's final economic growth for 2024 will fall between the 5.00% and 5.05% range.

In conclusion, the Indonesian economy is experiencing a complex phase characterized by sectoral disparities, regional variations, and slowed consumer spendingAs the nation navigates these challenges, the need for strategic interventions and policy measures becomes increasingly crucial to stabilize and invigorate economic growth moving forward.